March 24th, 2010
09:48 AM GMT
Share this on:

MTN bills itself as Africa's biggest cell phone operator. Either way, when you walk into the company's headquarters in Johannesburg they reek of success. The buildings are relatively new and have that expensive architectural look that allows for streams of natural light and other clever design tricks, which make you feel like you are in a contemporary art museum. Even the escalators and elevators look like art installations.

The reason I notice this is that many corporate headquarters are based, of course, in office blocks. No matter how plush the carpets, the environment still smacks of a charmless, gray place that makes me want to run screaming out of the swinging doors. So it makes a nice change to turn up for an interview and spend some of the pre-interview time admiring the company's interior design - there were cool chairs and fabulous art (a stunning Cecil Skotnes hung outside the ladies bathroom entrance.)

The CNN crew was treated to a generous lunch and the MTN staff couldn't have been friendlier or more helpful. I was looking forward to meeting Phuthuma Nhleko, the CEO who has been at the helm of one of Africa's corporate successes for eight years. He steps down next year after a tenure that has seen some spectacular growth in the telecoms market. Nhleko and his team have taken full advantage of these opportunities, particularly in emerging markets.  The group has operations in 21 countries across Africa and the Middle East, where they are in Syria, Afghanistan, Yemen and Iran.

Nhleko was, however, not that delighted to meet us. Perhaps it was because he had done more than twenty interviews that day to publicize MTN's annual results, or perhaps it was because I asked him questions that he didn't want to answer. Either way, Nhleko made it clear he was unhappy to be asked about aspects of MTN's presence in Iran, where it had "recorded a strong subscriber growth of 45 percent to 23.3 million in 2009, increasing its market share to 40 percent," according to the company's annual results media release.

Now, that is a sizable share of the Iran mobile phone industry, so I asked him, with the anti-government protests last year, if the Iranian government asked MTN to monitor phone calls or to turn off the network.  Remember, during the political turmoil after the 2009 disputed elections, there was global condemnation at the government's decision to limit internet access and filter content.

Also, of course, since the protests were largely communicated to the outside world via text messages and social networking sites like Twitter, they were recorded with cell phone cameras and emails were often sent via mobile phones.

So what was it like, literally, being the messenger in such a tense political environment?

Mr Nhleko said MTN "were not asked" to monitor and intercept SMSs, for example, and that the company complied with the Iranian license regulations. He did concede that "every country has got interception requirements for security."

Fair enough. But what about the moral angle? With South Africa's history, and the emphasis on freedom of speech and access to information, I asked him if he was uncomfortable having to work within the parameters of the Iranian regulations.

In a forceful but erudite manner he batted away my question, saying repeatedly that he thinks the company's role is to be a service provider and "not to make political commentary on any particular country."

He answered his questions with that steely self-confidence of a top-tier CEO who seems irritated with the nagging questions of a journalist, who kept on badgering him for an answer. I left wondering if perhaps he could have given our global audience - many of whom are MTN customers - a little more insight into how an industry-leading company does business in a geopolitical hotspot.  Whether he likes it or not, politics and business might not mix but they are inextricably linked.

More on Marketplace Africa >>

soundoff (9 Responses)
  1. Ali Reza

    The reason why Mr Nhleko could not answer you on these though questions is because the very license that they have is because of political reasons. MTN's partners (51%) is the defense ministry organization that is responsibile for the electronic systems of the Iranian missile programme. They get more than US$300 million every year from MTN Irancell for various services they provide. It is a bit of a nonsense for him to say that they were not asked to monitor SMS or calls. The company in Iran is managed by a Ministry of Defence official. There are more than 20 defense ministry employees (including the Chief Technical Officer) working for MTN Irancell. The Iranian government did not ask them to switch it off. They did it themselves because they are essentially another defense company.

    March 25, 2010 at 11:38 am |
  2. Li Ocean

    You were trying to be funny when there is nothing funny about the title or topic. Business and politics should not mix. if you want a business to be a global brand, you must be willing to work within the rules of the markets your in. You can't let your ideals go beyond what the consumers in that market can handle. If political change happens, it should always come from the consumers in that market first. your customers (in that market) should always have their needs met. They are the ones who decides. Businesses make money, not friends.

    March 26, 2010 at 6:36 am |
  3. Irvine Mawere

    and some people in the world got the nervous edge to say black AFRICA can no, I repeat CAN NOT sustain itself, the international community just has to help it break those inequalities which deeply divide africans most socially and economically, the job is done..

    Thank You

    March 26, 2010 at 8:12 am |
  4. Nana Kofi

    I watch the interview & I think most of Robyn's assertations about Phuthuma's demeanour is not accurate.

    March 29, 2010 at 3:32 am |
  5. Ben Dover

    I think Mr. Phuthuma Nhleko is more interested in his own pocket, rather than the future of iranian youth and their freedom of speech. of course if my company was making million of dollars with nonsense contracts from iranian department of defense, i would also close my mouth and divert all questions. however, let this be said that the world will never remail the same, and what goes up will one day come down. LONG LIVE FREE IRAN.

    March 29, 2010 at 8:53 am |
  6. Abbas

    You are cheap people, you really think that world will believe you are worried about Iranians be it youths, just shut up. look into your pathetic bully system and try to change it.

    April 4, 2010 at 10:15 am |
  7. Veronica

    When I worked at H&R Block I was badgered by the office manager who was a racist and against Barack Obama. The office manager saw me television at an Obama rally in La Crosse, Wisconsin, and she harassed me about wanting to vote for Obama. She said "how could you vote for that black ass". Of course the District Manager and Human Resource Manager did nothing to protect me from further harassment.

    April 5, 2010 at 7:55 pm |
  8. Loshen

    "I left wondering if perhaps he could have given our global audience – many of whom are MTN customers – a little more insight into how an industry-leading company does business in a geopolitical hotspot." Since Robyn failed with Phuthuma, perhaps she can try to ask the same of any of the US CEO's reaping in the profits in Iraq and/or Afghanistan. Or is the provision of aforementioned insight not really her objective?

    April 11, 2010 at 10:08 am |
  9. icons download

    Rather quite good topic

    November 4, 2012 at 2:05 pm |

Post a comment


CNN welcomes a lively and courteous discussion as long as you follow the Rules of Conduct set forth in our Terms of Service. Comments are not pre-screened before they post. You agree that anything you post may be used, along with your name and profile picture, in accordance with our Privacy Policy and the license you have granted pursuant to our Terms of Service.

About Business 360

CNN International's business anchors and correspondents get to grips with the issues affecting world business, and they want your questions and feedback.

Powered by VIP